New York vs San Francisco: Walkability Compared
New York is more walkable than San Francisco. New York scores 9.6/10 and San Francisco scores 9.1/10 on the SafeStreets 15-minute-city walkability score.
New York, NY and San Francisco, CA, side by side. Tier labels describe the average; specific addresses can vary block by block.
New York
Walkability score: 9.6/10 on the SafeStreets 15-minute-city walkability score (Pedestrian-first)
America's most walkable city, with extensive subway, dense sidewalk networks, and world-class pedestrian infrastructure across five boroughs.
What works:
- Most extensive subway system in the US with 472 stations providing 24/7 service
- Manhattan has one of the highest walk-to-work rates in the country at over 20%
- Dense mixed-use zoning means most daily needs are within a 10-minute walk
- Ongoing streetscape improvements including pedestrian plazas and protected bike lanes
Transit: MTA operates the largest transit system in North America: 472 subway stations across 26 lines with 24/7 service, plus an extensive bus network, commuter rail (LIRR, Metro-North), and the Staten Island Ferry.
What pulls walkability down:
- Aging subway infrastructure leads to frequent service disruptions and accessibility gaps -- only about 28% of stations are ADA-accessible
- Extreme sidewalk crowding in tourist-heavy areas like Midtown creates pedestrian bottlenecks
San Francisco
Walkability score: 9.1/10 on the SafeStreets 15-minute-city walkability score (Very walkable)
A compact, transit-rich city known for its steep hills, iconic streetcars, and walkable neighborhoods like the Mission and North Beach.
What works:
- Compact 7x7 mile footprint makes most of the city reachable on foot or by transit
- Muni runs bus, light rail, and the historic cable cars across the whole city
- High density of neighborhood commercial corridors with daily essentials within walking distance
- Strong protected bike lane network along Market Street and the Embarcadero
Transit: SFMTA Muni operates buses, light rail (Muni Metro), historic streetcars (F-line), and cable cars. BART provides rapid transit connections across the Bay Area. Caltrain serves the Peninsula corridor.
What pulls walkability down:
- Extreme hills in neighborhoods like Nob Hill and Pacific Heights make walking difficult for people with mobility limitations
- Sidewalk conditions vary significantly, with some neighborhoods facing encampment obstructions and deferred maintenance
Frequently Asked Questions: New York vs San Francisco
Is New York or San Francisco more walkable?
New York is more walkable than San Francisco. New York scores 9.6/10 and San Francisco scores 9.1/10 on the SafeStreets 15-minute-city walkability score.
Is New York walkable?
Yes — New York is a highly walkable city. New York scores 9.6/10 on the SafeStreets 15-minute-city walkability score (rated "Pedestrian-first").
Is San Francisco walkable?
Yes — San Francisco is a highly walkable city. San Francisco scores 9.1/10 on the SafeStreets 15-minute-city walkability score (rated "Very walkable").
New York walkability → · San Francisco walkability →
Cite as: SafeStreets by Streets & Commons. "New York vs San Francisco: Walkability Compared." https://safestreets.streetsandcommons.com/compare/new-york-vs-san-francisco
Built by Streets & Commons.