← All Insights
One city where half of households have no car
SafeStreets · Streets & CommonsUS Census ACS · August 2026
SafeStreets made this analysis from US Census American Community Survey neighborhood data. We combined the neighborhoods within 20 km of each city center and weighted them by population. We use two measures: households with no vehicle, and workers who drove alone to work. The method and its limits are at the end.
In New York, 52.5% of households have no vehicle. Philadelphia is second among the 50 largest US cities, at 22.5%. First place is thirty percentage points ahead of second place. Second place is only nineteen points ahead of fiftieth. On this measure, New York stands alone, and all the other large cities form one group far behind it.
Households with no vehicle available
New York
52.5%
Philadelphia
22.5%
Median of the 50 largest
8.5%
San Jose
3.7%
US Census ACS, neighborhoods within 20 km of the city centroid, population-weighted. SafeStreets analysis.
I started this work because the walkability scores on our own city pages did not match what residents would say. A score can describe a street, but it cannot show whether anyone can use the street. Car ownership can show this. A household without a car must get around on foot or by bus, or it cannot get around.
The median is 8.5%
Across the 50 largest US cities, the median share of households without a vehicle is 8.5%. Thirty-two of the fifty cities are below 10%. Twenty-seven are below the national average of 8.9%, and New York pulls that average up.
So in most large American cities, about one household in twelve lives without a car, and the other eleven own cars. Ownership does not show that those eleven households wanted cars. Where 65% of workers drive alone to work, a car is closer to a cost of living there than to a choice.
| City | Households with no vehicle | Drove alone to work |
|---|
| New York | 52.5% | 24% |
| Philadelphia | 22.5% | 55% |
| Chicago | 20.8% | 52% |
| Boston | 17.2% | 47% |
| Baltimore | 16.1% | 64% |
| San Francisco | 15.0% | 42% |
The six highest of the 50 largest US cities. US Census ACS, weighted by population over neighborhoods within 20 km of the city center.
The bottom of the table is not where you would guess
Of the fifty cities, San Jose has the lowest share of households without a car, at 3.7%. That is below Fort Worth and Albuquerque. San Jose has light rail and a mild climate. Its share of workers who drive alone, 61%, is lower than in Fort Worth. So fewer people in San Jose drive to work, but almost every household there owns a car.
| City | Households with no vehicle | Drove alone to work |
|---|
| San Jose | 3.7% | 61% |
| Boulder | 4.3% | 49% |
| Salt Lake City | 4.4% | 65% |
| Fort Worth | 4.7% | 73% |
| Albuquerque | 4.8% | 71% |
| Raleigh | 5.1% | 61% |
| Denver | 5.4% | 65% |
| Nashville | 5.5% | 67% |
The eight lowest of the 50 largest US cities, in order of the share of households with no vehicle.
Boulder shows the clearest gap between the two measures. Only 4.3% of its households have no car, which puts Boulder second from the bottom. But only 49% of its workers drive alone, and only a few cities on this list do better. Boulder residents own cars and leave them parked. This is a good result, and the car ownership figure does not show it.
Why the two numbers disagree
Car ownership and car use measure different things. Ownership shows whether a household can live without the cost of a car. Commuting shows what people do on a Tuesday morning. A city like Boulder can do well on commuting and badly on ownership. This happens when the city makes it easy to get to work without a car, but hard to live without one. For example, a household may have no grocery within a walk and no bus on Sunday. It may have no way to bring a child home from a clinic across town.
The opposite also happens. In Baltimore, 16.1% of households have no vehicle, and its share of workers who drive alone (64%) is almost the same as Denver's (65%). Both figures are true. Many Baltimore households cannot pay for a car, and most people who own one drive it alone to work.
What this does not show
These figures cover a 20 km radius around each city center. They do not follow city limits. The radius includes suburbs, so the figures describe the core of each metro area. With the five boroughs as the boundary, New York's 52.5% would be higher.
Some households cannot pay for a car, and others choose not to own one. The measure counts both groups together and cannot separate them. Baltimore's 16.1% and San Francisco's 15.0% are close, but they mean different things.
We chose not to report the share of people who walk or take transit to work. The same source table has these fields, but they failed our checks. The walk figure gives 1.5% for New York, and the published ACS figure is near 10%. The walk figure also never goes above 12.6% in any neighborhood in the country, which cannot be correct for Manhattan. We did not publish a figure that we could not match to the published data. The vehicle and drove-alone figures match the published ACS, so this article uses only those two.
Method
Source: US Census American Community Survey, 5-year estimates, at neighborhood level. For each of the 50 largest US cities, we took every neighborhood with its center within 20 km of the city center. We then calculated the population-weighted mean of two variables. The first is households with no vehicle. The second is workers aged 16 and over who drove alone to work. We left out cities with fewer than 20 valid neighborhoods. The national figures use the same calculation over all 159,227 valid neighborhoods.
We calculate the city walkability scores on this site separately, from street network and destination data. The scores have no part in the figures above. Where the two disagree, the city page shows both.
How to cite this analysis
Streets & Commons (2026). One city where half of households have no car. SafeStreets Insights. https://safestreets.streetsandcommons.com/insights/car-free-cities
Cite the underlying methodology and dataset together: doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20506270
Source repository: github.com/Poseidon-t/walkability-methodology. Licensed CC BY 4.0. Reproduction and redistribution encouraged with attribution.
More citable national figures: Walkability and Pedestrian Safety Statistics 2026
Now score your own street
Get a free score for how safe your street is to walk, measured the same way as the streets above.
Put these scores in your own product
Score any US address for walkability and pedestrian safety through the SafeStreets API or MCP server.
Free for 100 calls a month. Larger lists priced on a call.
Get API access
City walkability guides
The data behind this analysis
The scores behind this analysis are available through the SafeStreets API: walkability and pedestrian safety for any US address, free for 100 calls a month.
Get API access →Scoring your own address list? Book a call →