← All Insights
Tree canopy as walking infrastructure. Why Tucson walks less than Sacramento.
SafeStreets · Streets & CommonsUSFS UTC + NHTS · published June 2026
SafeStreets made this analysis. The canopy data comes from the US Forest Service Urban Tree Canopy assessment. The walking data comes from the National Household Travel Survey. The surface temperatures come from EPA Urban Heat Island monitoring and Open-Meteo land-surface readings.
In hot American cities, shade often decides whether people can walk a street. Sacramento and Tucson have similar summer temperatures, street grids and sidewalk coverage. Sacramento has three times more tree canopy. Per person, Sacramento residents walk about 24 percent more.
19%
Sacramento's tree canopy coverage, one of the highest of any large Western US city.
6%
Tucson's tree canopy coverage. The climate and the grid are similar to Sacramento, but the walking rate is very different.
Why shade is infrastructure
On a hot summer afternoon, black asphalt in direct sun can reach 138 degrees Fahrenheit. Gray concrete can reach 122 degrees. Under full canopy shade, the same surfaces stay between 78 and 86 degrees. This large gap decides whether a barefoot child or a small dog can walk on the surface.
Pedestrians feel the same gap as radiant heat. On a sidewalk in direct sun, the air feels 15 to 25 degrees hotter than under trees on the same sidewalk. In Phoenix in July, this gap separates a walk that is unpleasant from a walk that is dangerous.
| Surface condition | Surface temp at 95°F air (°F) | Feels-like increase to walker (°F) |
|---|
| Full canopy shade | 82 | +0 |
| 50% canopy shade | 96 | +8 |
| Full sun, gray concrete | 122 | +18 |
| Full sun, black asphalt | 138 | +25 |
EPA Urban Heat Island monitoring, summer 2023. Surface temperatures at 1pm on a day with 95°F air. The feels-like increase is how much hotter a person feels in direct sun than in shade, at the same air temperature.
The canopy table
Canopy varies widely across US cities, and local history explains it better than climate does. Atlanta has 47 percent canopy because postwar suburbs in the Southeast kept the pine forest. Phoenix has 4 percent because postwar builders in the Southwest cleared the desert plants and planted little. Sacramento has 19 percent because the city started a street-tree program in the 1950s.
| City | Tree canopy | Walking rate vs Houston baseline |
|---|
| Atlanta, GA | 47.1% | +18% |
| Charlotte, NC | 45.0% | +15% |
| Portland, OR | 30.7% | +11% |
| Minneapolis, MN | 26.4% | +7% |
| Sacramento, CA | 19.0% | +5% |
| Houston, TX | 18.4% | baseline |
| Denver, CO | 13.5% | -6% |
| Los Angeles, CA | 11.1% | -9% |
| Tucson, AZ | 6.4% | -19% |
| Phoenix, AZ | 4.3% | -24% |
US Forest Service Urban Tree Canopy assessment, most recent estimate for each city. The walking rate is walking trips per person per day from NHTS 2022, set against Houston. Houston has typical conditions for a hot American city.
Other causes count too, and the link is uneven. But the direction stays the same: people in cities with more canopy walk more. The effect is strongest in hot cities, where shade makes the largest difference. In Tucson and Phoenix, summer afternoons are often above 100 degrees. There, residents name the lack of shade more than any other reason for not walking on short trips.
Why Sacramento, specifically
Sacramento's high canopy comes from a plan. The city started its "City of Trees" street tree program in 1953, and the program has planted about 1.2 million trees since then. The Sacramento Tree Foundation started in 1982 and made the planting faster. The program puts street trees in the same budget line as paving and lighting. A city irrigation system waters the young trees for their first years.
Sacramento is in the Central Valley, where summer temperatures match Phoenix. But people can walk Sacramento's residential streets all summer, and they cannot walk Phoenix streets in the same way. Sacramento residents make about 40 percent more walking trips per person than Phoenix residents.
Now score your own street
Get a free score for how safe your street is to walk, measured the same way as the streets above.
Put these scores in your own product
Score any US address for walkability and pedestrian safety through the SafeStreets API or MCP server.
Free for 100 calls a month. Larger lists priced on a call.
Get API access
What canopy costs
A street tree costs about $300 to $500 to plant and about $50 a year to maintain for its first 20 years. After year 20, a healthy street tree needs almost no care. A tree gives benefits from cooling, stormwater absorption and cleaner air, and these benefits usually pass its cost by year 15. Over fifty years, one mature street tree gives about $30,000 in measured benefit to the city. Its total cost is about $1,500. The numbers favor trees, and the problem is funding.
What is moving
The federal Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 gave $1.5 billion to the US Forest Service Urban and Community Forestry program. The money pays for city tree planting through 2031, with a focus on poor communities. By mid-2025, the program had paid out about 30 percent. Detroit received one of the largest grants, at $23 million. Cleveland received $18 million and Phoenix $14 million.
A city that wants more canopy can plant the trees. The limits are which streets come first, and whether the city will care for new trees past year three. Most new city trees die within five years. In Sacramento, 89 percent of new trees are alive at year five. In Phoenix, the figure is 41 percent. Water and later care make the difference.
What you can do
If you live in a hot American city with less than 15 percent canopy, work on one street at a time. Find a walking route in your neighborhood with no shade. Send a photo to your council member and ask for a street-tree program. If your city has a tree foundation or a similar nonprofit, sign up to sponsor or care for a tree on the route. Most US cities let residents sponsor street trees on city land with a simple application.
The data behind this analysis
The scores behind this analysis are available through the SafeStreets API: walkability and pedestrian safety for any US address, free for 100 calls a month.
Get API access →Scoring your own address list? Book a call →
Sources & Methodology
Canopy data
US Forest Service Urban Tree Canopy assessment, most recent estimate for each city (2020 to 2024). Coverage is the percent of a city's land under tree canopy, measured with LiDAR and aerial images.
Surface temperature
EPA Urban Heat Island monitoring, summer 2023. Open-Meteo land-surface temperature readings. Surface temperatures at 1pm local time on a typical hot summer day in each city.
Walking rate
National Household Travel Survey 2022, walking trips per person per day for each metro area. A walking trip is any trip with mode=walking in the household trip log.
Sacramento program
City of Sacramento Urban Forestry Division historical records. Sacramento Tree Foundation annual reports 1982 to 2024.
Federal IRA funding
US Forest Service Urban and Community Forestry Program, Inflation Reduction Act 2022 allocation. Grant distributions per US Forest Service public records as of mid-2025.
What this analysis cannot say
Tree canopy is one of several causes of how much people walk. Sidewalks, street safety, transit and the mix of land uses also count. This article looks only at canopy, because in hot cities shade is often the strongest limit.
City walkability guides
How to cite this analysis
Streets & Commons (2026). Tree Canopy as Walking Infrastructure: Why Tucson walks less than Sacramento. SafeStreets Insights. https://safestreets.streetsandcommons.com/insights/tree-canopy-walking
Cite the underlying methodology and dataset together: doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20506270
Source repository: github.com/Poseidon-t/walkability-methodology. Licensed CC BY 4.0. Reproduction and redistribution encouraged with attribution.
More citable national figures: Walkability and Pedestrian Safety Statistics 2026